Our Blog

Southern Africa, Public Law Sophie Smit Southern Africa, Public Law Sophie Smit

The Role of the Judiciary in Protecting the Right to Administrative Action for Non‑Citizens

In this third installment of our series on democracy, exclusion, and participation, Sophie Smit discusses the judiciary's role in protecting non-citizens' right to administrative action in South Africa, focusing on the termination of the Zimbabwean Exemption Permit (ZEP) by the Department of Home Affairs. She notes that since non-citizens, including ZEP holders, lack the right to vote and thus political representation, they rely on the judiciary to protect their rights. Consequently, the Pretoria High Court found the termination unconstitutional due to a lack of fair process. She emphasizes the importance of the judiciary's duty to uphold constitutional rights for non-citizens while respecting executive decision-making.

Read More
Southern Africa, Public Law Marthinus van Staden Southern Africa, Public Law Marthinus van Staden

Guaranteeing Freedoms through Collective Action: The Role of Collective Action in Protecting Non-Voting Migrant Workers

In the second installment of our series on democracy, exclusion, and participation, Professor Marthinus discusses the uncertain position of migrant workers in South Africa, who contribute to the economy but are excluded from voting due to their non-citizen status. It explores alternative forms of engagement, like collective action, to protect their rights. Drawing on theoretical and legal frameworks, the article emphasizes the importance of balancing labor law enforcement with immigration enforcement to reduce fears of deportation in undocumented workers when trying to assert their rights. Also, the author observes that ensuring migrant workers can participate in collective actions, such as trade unionism, is crucial for safeguarding their rights and promoting a more inclusive democratic society.

Read More
East Africa, Human Rights William Aseka East Africa, Human Rights William Aseka

Intellectual Disability Should Not Bar Kenyan Citizens from Casting the Ballot

This week’s article addresses the exclusion of individuals with intellectual disabilities from voting in Kenya due to cultural biases, legal conflicts, and insufficiency. William Aseka advocates for legal amendments to reconcile conflicting constitutional articles and the introduction of supported decision-making. This would in turn enable intellectually disabled individuals to exercise their right to vote, aligning Kenya with international standards. He concluded by observing that ensuring voting rights for all, including those with intellectual disabilities, is essential for true democratic representation and inclusivity.

Read More
International Law, Southern Africa Brian Chihera International Law, Southern Africa Brian Chihera

Regional Citizenship as a Mode of Integration and Development within SADC: Lessons from the European Union

The Southern African Development Community (SADC) is committed to fostering economic development, peace, security, and growth, while also addressing poverty and improving the quality of life for the people of Southern Africa through Regional Integration. To realize these objectives, facilitating the free movement of people throughout the region is essential. Brian Chihera suggests that adopting a regional citizenship model akin to that of the EU could facilitate this. Under such a framework, citizens would enjoy increased access to resources, job opportunities, and social services.

Read More
Human Rights, International Law Bryony Fox Human Rights, International Law Bryony Fox

African Union’s new Protocol on statelessness: a beacon of hope for children’s rights

The African Union (AU) has taken a monumental step towards protecting the right to nationality in Africa. At the 37th Ordinary Session of the AU Assembly, the new Protocol to the African Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights was adopted, addressing the critical issue of statelessness. This historic move fills a crucial gap in the African Charter, ensuring the eradication of statelessness. Byrony Fox explores the significance of this Protocol and its impact on Human Rights in the region.

Read More
Constitutional Law Lindo Hadebe Constitutional Law Lindo Hadebe

The impeachment of Judge Hlophe and Judge Motata: A win for democracy and accountability

In this week’s post, Lindo Hadebe discusses the impeachment cases of two prominent South African judges. He observes that the impeachment signifies a pivotal moment in South Africa’s democracy. Thus, by addressing misconduct within the judiciary, South Africa took a significant step toward reinforcing the principles of democracy, transparency, and the rule of law. Despite the challenges inherent in the impeachment process, marked by prolonged legal battles, the impeachment reaffirmed the state’s commitment to upholding democratic values and preserving public trust in the judiciary’s integrity

Read More
South Africa, Citizenship laws Vhonani Neluvhalani-Caquece South Africa, Citizenship laws Vhonani Neluvhalani-Caquece

Defining the Content of the Right to Citizenship in South Africa through Ubuntu

This week’s post explores the concept of citizenship within the South African context, drawing upon the principle of Ubuntu. Through an analysis of the legal framework and current significant cases, the author highlights the disconnect between Constitutional ideals and their real-world application, especially concerning the acquisition of citizenship by non-citizens. In light of this, the author proposes a revaluation of citizenship through the lens of Ubuntu, advocating for more flexible and inclusive pathways to citizenship.

Read More
Constitutional Law, Human Rights Christy Chitengu Constitutional Law, Human Rights Christy Chitengu

Nurturing inclusivity: reforming citizenship laws for children born to foreign parents in South Africa

This article examines citizenship complexities in South Africa, centering on individuals born to foreign parents. It offers a critical analysis of s 4(3) of the Citizenship Act, asserting that the current provision, requiring individuals to wait until 18 for citizenship, is deserving of scrutiny. The author proposes a re-evaluation of this legal framework to foster greater inclusivity and equity. It

Read More
Kenya, Human Rights Joshua Malidzo Nyawa Kenya, Human Rights Joshua Malidzo Nyawa

Enlivening the Paramountcy of the ‘Best Interests of the Child’ Principle: Kenya’s Supreme Court Judgment

In a groundbreaking decision on September 8, 2023, Kenya's Supreme Court overturned rulings from lower courts that prioritised public interest over the "best interests of the child" principle. In this blog post, Joshua Nyawa discusses the significance of this judgement which redefined cases involving children accused of criminal offenses, emphasising the best interest of the child over mere public curiosity.

Read More
Kenya, Human Rights Tiffany Nzimbi Kenya, Human Rights Tiffany Nzimbi

Children’s Disability Rights: Access to Education for Children with Disabilities in Kenya

Education is a fundamental human right and many States have made a commitment to “ensure inclusive and equitable quality education and to promote lifelong learning opportunities for all” (see the Agenda 2030 on Education). Nevertheless, achieving this goal of granting everyone, equal access to a high-quality education regardless of their gender, race, and abilities remains a challenge. In this article, Tiffany examines some of the challenges faced by Kenyan disabled children in accessing education, and how the State has attempted to move its legal machinery to ensure the right is realised.

Read More
Southern Africa, Constitutional Law Shadi Maganoe Southern Africa, Constitutional Law Shadi Maganoe

Elections as an Accountability Mechanism during Times of Emergency

With the upcoming 2024 South African elections on the horizon, this week's post delves into the critical role of elections in holding the executive accountable. Shadi Maganoe examines the stance of South African courts regarding the challenges that emerged within the electoral system during the COVID-19 pandemic.

Read More

Submissions

 We welcome unsolicited submissions covering current legal developments in constitutional law, fundamental rights law, public law, international law and related fields.